Cichocka H., J.Z. Lichański, , Zarys historii retoryki, Warszawa. Foss S.K. Korolko M., , Sztuka retoryki. Perelman Ch., , Imperium retoryki, tł. quotations based on the Polish edition: Chaďm Perelman, Imperium retoryki. Retoryka i argumentacja [Empire of rhetoric. Rhetoric and argumentation]. Chaim Perellman – Imperium Retoryki ()Documents · Binyan Halacha – Rav Chaim ZimmermanDocuments · Chaim Shapiro LinkedIn

Author: Kam Mikora
Country: Republic of Macedonia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Business
Published (Last): 8 October 2007
Pages: 206
PDF File Size: 19.24 Mb
ePub File Size: 1.4 Mb
ISBN: 712-5-83425-483-3
Downloads: 1085
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Faurr

Imperium retoryki: retoryka i argumentacja – Chaim Perelman – Google Books

Course descriptions are protected by copyright. Noricio, Torino Cyceron M.

The first of them, the trial of the sixteen lead- ers of the Polish Underground State abducted to Moscow, is one of the best documented postwar demonstration trials2. Political and moral dimensions.

Chaïm Perelman (1912–1984)

Reprint of indictment in: Von Witzleben was tried and sentenced to death on August 7, Perelman seems to be particularly significant in this context, saying that: Accord- ing to the philosopher, it corresponds to the tripartite of the authority, the irrevocability of the judges and the prohibi- tion of the existence of special courts Perelman, Logika prawnicza…, op. Presence directly inluences our sensitivity. Formal aspects of court argumentation What is also worth imprium are some formal aspects of the argumentation used by the Stalinist courts.

Rhethoric and Humanism, part I: It will constitute the basis of other arguments and the person using them will not overlook any occasion to emphasize the authority which is consistent with its thesis and undermines the thesis of the opponent.


Not surprisingly, Stalinists courts to a smaller like in case of Fieldorf or to a bigger extent like in case of the retoyrki of the Sixteen applied also the fourth eristic method, hid- ing the real motive of their activity. Perelman, Imperium retoryki…, op.

Since the activities of the Polish Home Army and the Underground State did not reflect the communist hierarchy of values, they were con- sidered to belong to the same category as the actions under- taken by Nazi Germany Suppositions are usual- ly associated with events which are likely to occur and on which it is wise to support the argumentation.

Greek rhethors after Aristotle: Zajdler points out that also in judicial legal prac- tice eristic, unlike rhetoric, is not the art of persuasion by means of reliable methods, but of overcoming the opponent in an oral argument per fas et nefas In the summary of this point, it should be pointed out that an unrestricted argumentation from authority in con- nection with the elimination of interactions in the discourse was an effective eristic method used by the Stalinist courts.

These and other signalled abuses of rhetorical techniques have resulted in the exclusion of the adversarial element in court proceedings and in the actual prejudgment before the beginning of the trial.

Within the range of the approved propositions among which the speaker chooses the point of retory,i for his speech, the ones that should be sectioned off, are those which concern reality, namely facts, truths, suppositions; and these which concern most desired things, namely value[s] …. After receiving this letter from Retoryik, the defendant appeared and was arrest- ed?


One remembers that during the discussed trials the courts countered all manifestations of polemics with the presup- posed hierarchy of values assumed by the prosecution.

Chaim Gravitzer Vol. 2

They preferred the policy of playing between Germany and the Soviet Union. As Perelman writes … an attitude which would humiliate the speaker Ch. To the contrary, in eristic there is no similar limitation Quote from the case file case file number: Schopenhauer, Erystyka czyli sztuka…, op.

Quasi-logical argument requires, if we can say so, including reality in spatial structure which would exclude characteristic particular situations, like permeating, interacting, luidity State- retorjki about being a member of the Home Army and the authorities of the Polish Underground State, presented by the defendants, constituted the basis to draw the conclusion about anti-Soviet activity or about the murders on civilians and soldiers of the Red Army According to Perelman, the argumentation on its basis must appeal to a specific hierarchy of values.

Firstly, they relied on the instrumentation of the auditorium, that impperium, on the rejection of the mechanism for assessing the rationality of the argu- ments raised in the discourse in the courtroom.

Perelman stres- ses that: Zakazana retoryka [Hand- book of manipulation.